Getting a job offer from another company can be thrilling—it’s a recognition of your skills, value, and hard work. But just when you’re mentally preparing for the transition, your current employer throws a twist into the plot: a counteroffer. Now you’re caught between loyalty, opportunity, and the fear of making the wrong move.

So what should you do? Here’s a practical guide to help you confidently and professionally navigate a counteroffer.

1. Take a Step Back and Breathe

When your current employer counters your new job offer, it might feel flattering or even confusing. Before responding, take a moment to separate emotion from logic. It’s not just about money—it’s about your long-term goals, career growth, work culture, and values.

2. Understand Why You Wanted to Leave in the First Place

Most people start job hunting because something isn’t working: lack of advancement, toxic culture, underpay, burnout, or feeling undervalued. A counteroffer might offer more money or a new title, but will it fix those deeper issues?

Ask yourself:

• Were you growing and learning?

• Did you feel appreciated?

• Was leadership supportive?

• Did you see a future there?

If the answer to most of these is “no,” a counteroffer may just be a temporary bandage.

3. Assess the Counteroffer Objectively

Evaluate the counteroffer like you would a brand-new opportunity. Compare:

• Compensation and benefits

• Work-life balance

• Leadership and culture

• Growth opportunities

• Job security

Be honest: is this a genuine effort to retain you long-term or just a quick fix to avoid disruption?

4. Consider How It Might Change Your Relationship With Your Employer

Accepting a counteroffer can shift how your employer views you. Even if you stay, they may question your loyalty or future commitment. You might be passed over for promotions or high-visibility projects because they fear you might leave again.

Meanwhile, the new company that made the offer likely saw you as a long-term investment, not a short-term plug.

5. Don’t Burn Bridges Either Way

Whether you accept the counteroffer or move on, handle it with professionalism. Thank both sides for the opportunity, be honest (but not emotional), and show appreciation. You never know when paths may cross again.

Sample response:

“I truly appreciate the counteroffer and the vote of confidence. After careful thought, I’ve decided to pursue the new opportunity as it aligns better with my long-term goals. I’m committed to ensuring a smooth transition and appreciate all I’ve gained here.”

6. Trust the Data (and Your Gut)

According to various studies, 50-80% of people who accept a counteroffer end up leaving within 6-12 months anyway—either because nothing really changed or because trust broke down.

If your instinct says the new opportunity offers more than just a raise—like a healthier work environment or growth potential—it’s worth serious consideration.

Final Thought: A Counteroffer Isn’t a Win or a Trap—It’s a Test

A counteroffer can be flattering, but it’s also a powerful moment of clarity. It forces you to define what matters most in your career.

Don’t let fear or guilt make your decision. Choose the path that aligns with your values, vision, and worth.

Because your career isn’t just about the next paycheck—it’s about the next chapter.

Want more career advice like this? Subscribe for weekly insights on navigating job changes, negotiating offers, and building a fulfilling career.